The Forum > Article Comments > What is a child? > Comments
What is a child? : Comments
By Bob Ryan, published 13/1/2010A child is defined by age, which is not always consistent with the age of consent, or age of majority.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- Page 5
-
- All
I'm afraid they do dear, which is why I posted the links. Each of my quotes is a direct C&P from the reports I cited.
pynchme:"the definitions of child abuse have changed and broadened."
Yes, they have. So have the definitions of sexual assault and domestic violence. I know you support the broadening in those fields, so why do you not support it in this case? could it be that in the other cases they've been broadened to include normal male behaviours, while in the case of kids they've been broadened to include normal female behaviours in recognition of the damage done to kids by abusive or emotionally manipulative mothers?
The first lnk you posted relies heavily on a study of 50 selected (not random) children from severely dysfunctional families and on US "studies" from back in the 60s. Hardly relevant to anything other than getting grants for the author.
The second report makles no assessment of perpetrator gender and provides no data. it does say "The deaths of children from assault are rare in NSW, accounting for only 1.4 per cent of all the deaths of children and young people aged 0-17 over the ten-year period 1996 to 2005." Are you suggesting we should be basing our child protection policies on 1.4% of situations?
your third link is dated 2003) but contains the following quote:"Women commit between 31-50 percent of physical assaults on children.
Mothers commit almost 50 percent of the recorded infanticide and women perpetrate between 2-7 percent of sexual assaults against children.
It is worth noting that often researchers identify that, for example, 69 percent of perpetrators of such and such crime are men, but then fail to discuss who perpetrated the remaining 31 percent."
The AIC link is from 1996; it is irrelevant, and the last has nothing to do with Australia.
What are you going to post next, Nancy Astor's speech to the suffragettes in 1902?