The Forum > Article Comments > The Goldstone Report and the allegations against Israel > Comments
The Goldstone Report and the allegations against Israel : Comments
By Sharene Hambur, published 23/10/2009The Goldstone Report and the United Nations Human Rights Council: anti-Israel politicisation with far-reaching ramifications
- Pages:
-
- Page 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
-
- All
Here we see a gross political imbalance within the United Nations Human Rights Council (UNHRC) where, instead of being an arbiter for peace, it is clandestinely setting the stage for a further and heightened conflict.
Posted by relda, Friday, 23 October 2009 9:34:58 AM
| |
What a litany of half truths,misleading statements and downright ,blatant zionist propaganda.It is not worthy of detailed criticism but to say we all know Israel moved their occupation out of Gaza but what you just failed to say is that Israel has constantly harassed the population with continuing military operations with the major 'Cast Lead' campaign destroying homes and killing in excess of 1400 and injuring many more as the IDF has continued to do since occupation of Palestine in 1948.
You now fear your latest, recorded and reported actions have exposed the lie which is the jewish state of Israel to a world who believed you were all Holocaust survivors. The sooner this Ziono-fascist state of Apartheid collapses, the better. The Goldstone Report must be discussed in the U.N. and it's deliberations made public so we can all study the contents and judge for ourselves. Posted by maracas1, Friday, 23 October 2009 11:01:37 AM
| |
Israel has been accused of terrorist acts and crimes against humanity.
The biggest condemnation of the Israeli attacks on Gaza comes from their own mouths. There was a 99% success rate of hitting what they targeted. This means they deliberately targeted schools, hospitals, kindergartens, water infrastructure, greenhouses, chicken farms, cement plants, public buildings, sewage treatment plants (deliberately hit so as to release as much raw sewage as possible) mosques, wells, flour mills and homes. This is without doubt terrorism. The deliberate targeting of civilians. Mistreatment of prisoners, using human shields, indiscriminate mortar shelling and use of flechettes. All war crimes. All commited by Israel in its attack on Gaza. Why did they do this? For "the specific purpose of denying their use for the sustenance of the civilian population of the Gaza Strip", which was "part of a policy of collective punishment of the civilian population". This takes place in the context of a "military doctrine that views disproportionate destruction and creating maximum disruption in the lives of many people as a legitimate means to achieve military and political goals". "Statements by political and military leaders prior to and during the military operations in Gaza leave little doubt that disproportionate destruction and violence against civilians were part of a deliberate policy" Terrorism! Israel is a terrorist state. No where have I yet seen any evidence that Israelis or their supporters have even read the Goldstone report. They certainly are doing everything they can to defame its author but they have not said a single word to refute any of the charges leveled at them. Bring them before the ICC and then we can see the truth and stop them doing this to any of their neighbors ever again. Posted by mikk, Friday, 23 October 2009 12:03:04 PM
| |
It's sort of funny in a horrifyingly disgusting way that states like China, Saudi Arabia, and even Iran, have chaired the UN Human Rights Panel - which decides
Think of all the filthy practices these nations have, even slavery of SE Asian workers in Arab states, trafficking of kids as soldiers in Africa, and filthy Cuba where it's own people risk death by swimming to Miami! And these scum cultures dare to condemn the only democratic state in the whole backward mid-east region? Where Arabs are treated better in Israel than in their own vile nations? They should be bombed just for daring to criticise civilised people in the first instance, and bombed again because they are so devoid of logic. Israel is like a flower in a region of hopeless waste. The UN should only have members like Australia, US, Canada, and western European nations in Scandanavia, etc. Even Italy, Greece and other souther European states shouldn't be allowed in, due to their corruption. Third world filth should eventually be allowed in, but only after proving they are not 3rd world filth anymore - where taxi drivers rob tourists, police rape prisoners, etc. UN is hopeless. Good on US and UK for ignoring it during Iraq war. We should stop funding it immediately unless my preconditions are met. Posted by Benjam1n, Friday, 23 October 2009 1:56:45 PM
| |
Mikk
You say, "No where have I yet seen any evidence that Israelis or their supporters have even read the Goldstone report. They certainly are doing everything they can to defame its author but they have not said a single word to refute any of the charges leveled at them." I was surprised to read this as there are numerous detailed reports available on the internet which expose many of the report's flaws. If you are interested below is a link to one such report. http://honestreporting.com/articles/45884734/critiques/new/The_Goldstone_Report_Rewarding_Palestinian_Terror.asp Posted by Poppyseed, Friday, 23 October 2009 3:32:40 PM
| |
sorry poppy that article does not address a single incident or criticism within the Goldstone report.
For example justify the bombing of the Al Bader flour mill. At the start of the attack the Al Bader flour mill was the only flour mill in the Gaza Strip still operating. The flour mill was hit by a series of air strikes on 9 January 2009 after several false warnings had been issued on previous days. The Mission finds that its destruction had no military justification. The nature of the strikes, in particular the precise targeting of crucial machinery, suggests that the intention was to disable the factory in terms of its productive capacity. WAR CRIME! The chicken farms of Mr. Sameh Sawafeary in the Zeitoun neighbourhood south of Gaza City reportedly supplied over 10 per cent of the Gaza egg market. Armoured bulldozers of the Israeli forces systematically flattened the chicken coops, killing all 31,000 chickens inside, and destroyed the plant and material necessary for the business. The Mission concludes that this was a deliberate act of wanton destruction not justified by any military necessity and draws the same legal conclusions as in the case of the destruction of the flour mill. WAR CRIME! Israeli forces also carried out a strike against a wall of one of the raw sewage lagoons of the Gaza Waste Water Treatment Plant, which caused the outflow of more than 200,000 cubic metres of raw sewage into neighbouring farmland. The circumstances of the strike on the lagoon suggest that it was deliberate and premeditated. WAR CRIME! Taking into account the ability to plan, the means to execute plans with the most developed technology available, and statements by the Israeli military that almost no errors occurred, the Mission finds that the incidents and patterns of events considered in the report are the result of deliberate planning and policy decisions. ISRAELS LEADERS ARE WAR CRIMINALS! How about some answers and less of the rhetoric, propaganda and slander from you Israeli apologists. Posted by mikk, Friday, 23 October 2009 5:07:14 PM
|