The Forum > Article Comments > Asylum seekers or economic refugees? > Comments
Asylum seekers or economic refugees? : Comments
By Mike Pope, published 23/10/2009Are the Sri Lankans genuine asylum seekers? Or are they economic migrants, aspiring to socio-economic conditions they could never enjoy in India or Sri Lanka?
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- Page 4
-
- All
>>The article you quote is interesting but very misleading and policially biased<<
The only part that is misleading is the mannner in which I introduced it, in answer to ozzie's "Do we take this many? I haven't seen the figures"
Which of course was not the question that the article was addressing at all.
Because it clearly states that what was actually being measured,was:
"...how many applications for asylum Australia and other countries have received this year"
Applications, GIAO. Not acceptances. Applications.
Mea culpa.
So you see, there is no "political bias" at all in the numbers, just a straight factual reporting from UNHCR statistics.
Which would explain why there are so few countries on the list - you'd hardly expect a long queue of applicants for, say, Somalia. Would you?
The article also points out that actual acceptances differ...
"Cyprus is receiving a large number of applications, but it appears that far fewer are being allowed to stay,"
So we are still in the dark about where we stand on the humanitarian league table.
Sorry to mislead.