The Forum > Article Comments > Kevin Rudd's spin on capitalism is almost pure myth > Comments
Kevin Rudd's spin on capitalism is almost pure myth : Comments
By Leon Bertrand, published 2/2/2009Rudd’s plan to bring back levels of spending, regulation and protectionism similar to the 70s is a betrayal of his claim that he is an economic conservative.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- Page 6
-
- All
You are correct, exchange rates were fixed and in many countries citizens were not allowed to own gold. That is not capitalism.
Governments had very strict import and export controls for restraint of trade reasons; you could not import a large aircraft into this country without government permission to protect the Ansett/TAA duopoly. Rail had government protection from the trucking industry. Capitalism?
Farm produce had (and has still in many cases) to be sold through monopoly marketing boards. That is not capitalism. Neither are the huge EU and US agricultural subsidies – then and now – any part of capitalism.
Labour is permitted to organise and bargain in a monopoly manner but business is not permitted to do so. Capitalism? Nope.
Government controls traditional media ownership to restrict normal business transactions and in the case of TV to preclude entry of new players – not capitalism.
Private health facilities exist in Australia (and US, UK) but do not flourish because of government run hospitals BUT as recent events particularly in NSW show, the government system is not coping. Doctors, food and drug suppliers not paid for six weeks? No morphine in a major base hospital? No anaesthetist available outside business hours at a major hospital hundreds of miles from an alternative? Illegal to insure for medical disaster (IE a bill over $5000 say) to compel people to be “community rated”. Not capitalism and all contributing to particularly Kruddy health services. Health administrations have lots of money – but not to provide services; look at the offices in your state.
Capitalism would ensure a viable electricity grid; more frequent failures are certain in future as governments limit investment returns and in NSW, maintain government ownership of generation – good luck when both fail and people die!
No, CAPITALISM has not failed; it has not been tried yet. GOVERNMENT has failed. The remedy is not more government. Businesses have to be efficient to survive; government acts without competition, no incentive to be efficient, plenty of scope for corruption. QED.