The Forum > Article Comments > Anti-dogmatism > Comments
Anti-dogmatism : Comments
By Peter Sellick, published 7/4/2008Anti-dogmatism is alive and well. There are many clergy in the Anglican and Uniting denominations who proudly turn their back on the formal study of theology.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- ...
- 5
- 6
- 7
- Page 8
- 9
- 10
- 11
- 12
- 13
- 14
-
- All
>> your religiosity and your fine ability to conceive abstracts mathematically are linked <<
I am not sure what you mean by religiosity, but yes, a person’s world view and his/her specialisation are always linked. A doctor or psychologist will have a different insight into, say, faith and the associated tenets, than a physicist like Polkinghorne, or a mathematician.
>> a manifold can reside across multi-verses <<
Manifolds (carrying, say, a pseudo-Riemannian structure, like those used to model space-time in Einstein’s GR) are pure mathematical concepts that - mathematical Platonists believe - have their own independent existence, hence “reside“ in a world of their own, independent of the physical world (see e.g. Penrose). The Multiverse, if it exists apart from our universe, still belongs to the physical world, and manifolds “reside“ in them as little as the telescope you look through at Alpha Centauri “reside“s in that stellar constellation.
>> manifold ... and the conception of Theism are both abstracts? <<
I ma not sure I understand what you mean. My previous remarks about the relation between mathematics and the physical world are independent of what one thinks about the existence of God (irrespective of how you define both “existence” and “God”).
However, you are right in the sense that what I know (or think I know) about the relation between the mathematical and physical worlds INSPIRES my understanding of the rationale behind my faith, i.e. the relation between the world of theological concepts and dogmas, and the Transcendental that they are supposed to refer to. If you like, for me mathematics helps me to follow Anselm‘s maxim about my faith seeking understanding. Nevertheless, this is a strictly personal inspiration that I would not like to turn into some kind of universal recipe for finding that understanding.