The Forum > Article Comments > Taxing position, position, position > Comments
Taxing position, position, position : Comments
By Nicholas Gruen, published 12/4/2005Nicholas Gruen argues for progressive taxation on 'status' or 'positional' goods.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- Page 2
-
- All
Posted by trade215, Thursday, 14 April 2005 4:26:02 PM
|
Progressive taxation strikes me as Doublethink. What is progressive about punishing someone for earning more? What is progressive about arbitrarily confiscating a larger proportion of an individual's labour or productive output just because they earn more. We can do essentailly the same work but be paid vastly different amounts. Like a CEO who works for a prestigious firm earning 10 times more than another CEO at a less prestigious company. Both with fundamentally similar work loads. Under 'progressive' taxation the one who earns more effectively spends a greater portion of their life 'working for the man.' Why should one have to work roughly 9 months of the year to feed the system, whilst their neighbour works 3 months in the year to feed it? Where is the fairness in that.
Progressive tax aims to homogonise us, drag us all down/up to a level of acceptable mediocrity and control our vanity and envy.
We live in a Robinhood society. Robbing Peter to pay Paul. As long as your Paul and not Peter, most seem quite happy with that.