The Forum > Article Comments > Nuclear power is no panacea for climate change > Comments
Nuclear power is no panacea for climate change : Comments
By Donna Green, published 27/1/2005Donna Green argues that there are hidden costs in using nuclear energy.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- Page 2
-
- All
Not that Dr. Green's concerns about nuclear energy are not well-founded: it is VERY important that we insist on the absolute best science and engineering in considering to use nuclear technology.
While I applaud and support all efforts to hold the nuclear industry accountable to strict science and safety, Dr. Green gets herself tripped up on some poorly thought-out assumptions, chief of which appears to be that she believes that there is no possible role for nuclear energy to generate electrical power in the future of our civilization.
Despite underlying concerns which she has about nuclear safety, her hypotheses about the economics and trade-offs of the energy sector input/output matrix are sloppy, as all of the previous responders have pointed out in one way or another.
There are certainly hidden costs in any undertaking, such as owning a home, but Dr. Green appears to be the tail wagging the dog in suggesting that either (1) a free market economy with appropriate government leadership and protections is incapable of solving that equation, or alternatively that (2) capitalism is an inherently flawed vehicle of providing long-term social well being, supported perhaps by the claim that the nuclear industry is some form of corrupt racket, propped up by the vested interests of a small number of political and corporate leaders who have managed to pull the wool over all of our eyes and are selling us a load of deadly bricks so that they may prosper in the short-term.
Nuclear energy is not a panacea by any means, but it will sure look more attractive when the planet starts to run out of oil and gas. We should not wait to develop the proper methods to harness and control that source of energy until we are forced to do it in a rushed and hurried fashion under global economic duress, for then we would certainly be inclined to make more errors than with a well-planned approach over time.