The Forum > Article Comments > Killing koalas: the promise of extinction Downunder > Comments
Killing koalas: the promise of extinction Downunder : Comments
By Binoy Kampmark, published 6/7/2020Environmental degradation, anthropogenic meddling and all around beastliness to country, has made Australia a titan of destructiveness.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
-
- All
Posted by diver dan, Monday, 6 July 2020 8:53:02 AM
| |
Koalas! The so called leaders of this country need to start showing respect and care for people before they spend time thinking about animals.
Posted by ttbn, Monday, 6 July 2020 9:36:04 AM
| |
Koalas are really expert at surviving in the Australian bush including wild fires.
The Australian Koala conservancy is really expert at touching up punters and government and getting money from them. Between them the Koalas are not going to go extinct and the Aust Koala conserving mob are not going broke. Hey it is always good when someone shows how "Woke" they are, how caring and how much they love other people money. Are we all happy now? Posted by JBowyer, Monday, 6 July 2020 9:54:55 AM
| |
An interesting article that acknowledges the range of views on what is a complex issue, but ultimately lets itself down by choosing a side based on what appears to be little more than the author's personal leanings and a want to believe that a Government Committee (chaired by the Greens no less) has irrefutable credibility.
The problem with this issue (and others involving forest-based wildlife) is the over-reliance on the views of ecologists and activists with no practical appreciation of forest management, despite the reality that the conservation of such species is intricately intertwined with the state of forests and how they are managed. The author is happy to refer to affected industry and its workers as lobbyists, but somehow neglects to mention that those on the other side, such as the NSW National Parks Association which is the proponent of the idea of ending timber production as the species' saviour, are also lobby groups campaigning on ideological (as distinct from practical) grounds. Contrary to eco-activist ideologues, those with a strong practical appreciation of koala habitat and distribution have noted that the species thrives in areas where there is a surplus of vigorous young tree growth with soft, succulent foliage. Such areas include regrowth from past logging and fire, and eucalypt timber plantations. Indeed, in SW Victoria, koalas have exploded to plague proportions in blue gum plantations established from the mid-1990s. On the other hand, forest areas 'preserved' in national parks can grow old and moribund and progressively become unsuitable for koalas - until the next fire renews the trees. The Tantawanglo Koala Nature Reserve is an example of what can happen when areas are set aside specifically for koalas -- within 20 years, the species had moved out into surrounding State Forests where limited logging had created a more favourable mix of old trees and young regrowth. Posted by MW Poynter, Monday, 6 July 2020 11:13:23 AM
| |
DD,
The only species in plague proportions is Homo Sapiens. A virus and a parasite on this planet. Posted by ateday, Monday, 6 July 2020 11:15:40 AM
| |
Only couple of years ago we were told that thre ere so many koala bears on kangaroo island that they needed to be culled, and that the SA government was considering using shooters to shoot koala bears out of the trees.
Now we are told that they are facing extinction. Somebody is telling porky pies. I think this is another "crown of thorns" issue. Somebody just wants more government money for their own little bureaucratic empire. we were once told that unless the government took action, now, the crown of thorns was going to destroy the Great Barrier Reef. But the reef and the crown of thorns are still there. Posted by LEGO, Monday, 6 July 2020 11:21:29 AM
| |
LEGO,
They are no relation to bears, mate; but yes, they are a damn nuisance on KI, where they were INTRODUCED from Queensland or some such place where they reached plague proportions. They are cute, and nobody likes to see them burnt. But cute and cuddly should be left to children; adults need to start acting like adults and start telling econuts to pee off. Posted by ttbn, Monday, 6 July 2020 11:58:03 AM
| |
Yep ateday
I did get a bit carried away giving whales a green light for the use of plague. And I one hundred percent agree, humans appear to be an unstoppable plague on this earth. Since God died last century, humans are now perched at the apex of the pecking order, with only themselves as their own worst enemy. In time, that paradox should have comforting outcomes, leaving over-populationists satisfied. After all, what could possibly go wrong with Trump and China trading blows. Dan Posted by diver dan, Monday, 6 July 2020 12:58:05 PM
| |
Under new Chinese management they'll probably be eaten.
Our tyranny of experts is taking us there. Intriguing how the number of ecological problems seem to grow along with funding for the study of ecological problems. Posted by jamo, Monday, 6 July 2020 2:51:55 PM
| |
Koalas in SA aren't endangered. They've started moving into the Adelaide suburbs, much like the roos did in Canberra.
There are some endangered koala populations in the eastern states, due to loss of habitat. But pretending they're headed for extinction is a terrible distraction from the less charismatic animals that are actually in danger of extinction. Posted by Aidan, Monday, 6 July 2020 5:46:35 PM
| |
Pigs will fly before koalas become extinct.
https://quadrant.org.au/opinion/doomed-planet/2020/07/koalas-versus-experts/ http://joannenova.com.au/2020/07/koalas-extinct-no-chance-its-just-another-man-made-boom-n-bust-cycle/ you should get an education Binoy Posted by Little, Monday, 6 July 2020 5:56:27 PM
| |
Indeed Little. In that article Vic correctly raises the point of numbers going up and down with the food supply. Normal for all species.
Improve a bit of pasture and the browsing animal numbers explode. Same happens with introduced species. For a number of years after calici was released feral cats seemed to be increasing in number but now they've dropped back off. Probably more a case of needing to find another food source made the cats more visible until their numbers dropped from the loss of their easy food supply. Posted by jamo, Monday, 6 July 2020 6:35:17 PM
| |
Yes Little, Binoy does have a habit of writing on subjects where he has absolutely no idea of the facts. Should endear him to the ABC & it's supporters.
Posted by Hasbeen, Tuesday, 7 July 2020 1:12:01 AM
|
Of course, the above comes with confrontation which is not always popular.
Dan