The Forum > Article Comments > Facts about the phonics screening check > Comments
Facts about the phonics screening check : Comments
By Jennifer Buckingham, published 28/8/2017It’s astonishing that much of what is written in opposition to the Phonics Screening Check is inaccurate.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- Page 2
-
- All
This pseudo-words business, my curiosity got the better of me and I just had to go and investigate - who exactly came up with that rubbish?
Its one thing to teach sounds like 'at' as in 'The fat cat shat on the mat' (again); but teaching kids the wrong words, saying 'they don't know any better in Grade 1', words like 'bam' goos' 'zack' 'plock', these are bloody comic book words out of Batman fight scenes.
Are you teaching kids reading with comic books now?
Holy crap, I'm not sure if this saga is getting better or worse.
Think I'm gonna go with worse, since I'm maybe not sure which planet I'm on.
Comic book words? Really?
http://www.lcp.co.uk/phonics-screening-pseudo-words
Seems like laziness on the part of idiot teachers who's own reading skills never got past comic book stage, or perhaps that's how those teachers themselves learned to read?
(comic books come after you actually learn to read, when it should be picked up on that those pseudo words are in fact pseudo words)
All I know is this, go back 30yrs ago, and more or less every single kid learned how to do it, good enough to get by.
I could say that kids aren't sitting around reading choose your own adventures anymore like we did as kids, and are on gaming consoles and youtube instead.
But sureley gaming consoles and computers provide opportunity to read as well, so I can't help thinking that a big part of it is teachers curriculum.
I'd say the blind leading the blind, but it's more like the illiterate leading the illiterate.
Comic Books!!
I wonder whether theres a point a person gets to in life where they reach a pinnacle, where the world is just so full of crap that nothing surprises you anymore.
Teaching kids to read using comic book words, maybe this is it for me and it's all downhill from here..