The Forum > Article Comments > Reining markets in > Comments
Reining markets in : Comments
By Geoff Davies, published 11/12/2013The free market mantra is not about to disappear from the Australian political landscape - far from it - but really it's time some logic was brought to bear on this brutal ideology.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- Page 4
- 5
- 6
-
- All
Here's just one example, from the section "Pyramids and Ponzi Schemes"
"If the price of oranges goes up, this counts as contributing to inflation. If the price of housing goes up, it isn’t counted towards inflation."
Fact check:
"...the Housing group includes all expenditure on rents, utilities, purchase and maintenance of dwellings and other expenditure on shelter-related goods and services. The Housing group accounted for just over 22% of the CPI expenditure in the 16th series CPI weighting pattern, introduced in the June quarter 2011."
http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/mf/6461.0
If this was merely an opinion you were expressing, you might get away with it. After all, we all have our opinions. But you out yourself as a complete fabricator in the next sentence...
"I’ve had occasion to ask an economist if this is really true, and why. The response has gone something like “Oh yes well … technical reasons … international comparisons … mumble mumble … OECD … blah blah”. But , I say, isn’t it a major omission? After all, the rent or the mortgage payment is one of the biggest, often the biggest, expense for your average family. Buying the family home is the biggest investment most people make. More mumbling."
Sadly, this sort of baloney is a recurring theme throughout the pamphlet. As is the chutzpah with which lines such as this are delivered:
"Anyway, it seems I just explained the GFC in a couple of pages of fairly plain English. Certainly there were other factors involved, some more of which I’ll mention shortly, but I think we’ve covered the essence. Yet it seems this explanation has never occurred to the economists in charge of major economies."
You may think you "explained the GFC", Mr Davies but you did so with pretty much the same level of comprehension as an economist would bring to bear to "explain" mantle dynamics.