The Forum > Article Comments > Where are you from? > Comments
Where are you from? : Comments
By Ramesh Fernandez, published 29/6/2012Do you realise that the question 'Where do you come from?' immediately sets in place a structure that excludes people, rejecting them with a form of passive racism?
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- ...
- 9
- 10
- 11
- Page 12
- 13
- 14
-
- All
thanks for your entertaining response but I wasn't enquiring as to the aboriginal problem "then", but now. I asked above, "If we no longer subscribe to supremacist notions of racial inferiority, how do we explain that our native pariahs are in such a comparatively appalling state?"
I've been saying it's not "about where you’re from, but what you look like", and that it's not just about how you're treated based on appearance, but how you "learn to perceive yourself".
Rhrosty,
yep we are a land of immigrants, in degrees of separation.
Grim,
fine, immigrant means new arrival, yet I stand by my cultural tossed salad analogy, nor does the cultural influence of the respective mother country cease upon the demise of the first generation. Les Murray continues to celebrate his Scottish ancestry. Australia is hardly "Australia" as anything distinctive; it's an outlying wealthy suburb of Europe and America. Despite the endless patronage of politicians, being Australian doesn't mean a damn thing. As for "guilt", I'm not asking anyone to feel guilty about the past. Nor about the present. I don't. As I keep saying, I'm talking about the influence and victims of prejudice based on appearances, including the self-harming behaviour of aboriginal "identity" (since it's being argued they barely exist anymore). But the enclaves of "Australian" (ie second, third generation) Vietnamese, Lebanese, Indian, African etc. are maintained, in my opinion, much more by the bigotry and provincialism of "real Australians", based on appearance, than their own sectarianism. Much of the disharmony between the Australian mainstream and ethnic groups is set-up and exacerbated by reciprocal perceptions. Some ethnic groups, say middle eastern, react aggressively to the negative perceptions they register, and some, like many aboriginals, seem utterly defeated in their abject social status and are destructive generally.
Such anyway is my rudimentary thesis. I don't tell anybody else what to think.